Pound-for-pound top five D1 wrestlers in 2023-24

[peanut]

Here's who I have:

1. Starocci
2. Brooks
3. Vito
4. KOT
5. Carr

[scourge165]

34 minutes ago, peanut said:

Here's who I have:

1. Starocci
2. Brooks
3. Vito
4. KOT
5. Carr

Assuming everyone that has eligibility and hasn't yet choosen to forgo it is eligible and we're looking at next year;

 

--I actually got to 3 and all I'd done was flip Brooks and Starocci. It's SO hard to put anyone ahead of Vito right now though. The way I watched him smoke RBY and Fix...IDK, at this moment, I might have him #1. Brooks and Starocci are better overall in terms of their careers, but Vito wrestled at a level I haven't seen many(Any?) '33 pounders Wrestle at.

 

[peanut]

27 minutes ago, scourge165 said:

Assuming everyone that has eligibility and hasn't yet choosen to forgo it is eligible and we're looking at next year;

 

--I actually got to 3 and all I'd done was flip Brooks and Starocci. It's SO hard to put anyone ahead of Vito right now though. The way I watched him smoke RBY and Fix...IDK, at this moment, I might have him #1. Brooks and Starocci are better overall in terms of their careers, but Vito wrestled at a level I haven't seen many(Any?) '33 pounders Wrestle at.

 

Yeah Vito might be the best. Tough to say, obviously. 

[scourge165]

55 minutes ago, peanut said:

Yeah Vito might be the best. Tough to say, obviously. 

I really started the list, but I couldn't disagree with anyone. I can't put Kerk on there as bad as he looked or...Keckeisen or whoever, so it's these 5. 

Next 5 would be MUCH more difficult. 

-Real Woods
-Mekhi Lewis
-Fix(Might be knocking him unfairly, but last impressions)
-Lovett
-Haines
-Greg Kerkvliet
-Gomez...I guess. I still like him.
-Rocky Elam

[ionel]

15 hours ago, peanut said:

Here's who I have:

1. Starocci
2. Brooks
3. Vito
4. KOT
5. Carr

Even with the "serious" knee injury?  

[500 wrestler]

I’d put Sammy Sasso at 6. Even before stellar performance at US open. And his trajectory seems up as opposed to Lewis and Fix.